2020 was a challenging year for all of us but it was especially hard for high school seniors as the expectations of lavish graduation parties, prom dresses, and college-bound dreams were dashed in a matter of days. From director Peter Nicks and produced by Ryan Coogler, Homeroom follows the 2019-2020 class of Oakland High School seniors as they attempt to create systemic change and leave a lasting legacy in their hometown while adjusting to life in a pandemic.
Homeroom feels very much like A24’s Boys State in the way it captures intimate and vulnerable moments from impressionable and impassioned teenagers. Sticking to his signature style of vérité filmmaking, Peter Nicks observes a handful of students as they prepare to submit college applications, sit through mundane history lectures, attend various club meetings, and rehearse for the school play.
The documentary begins in the fall of 2019–pre-pandemic–when the biggest topic of conversation is the ethics of policing in schools. Students want to defund the police, citing that implicit bias sparks unnecessary fear, especially in predominately black and brown schools like theirs. Their arguments are articulate and strong, appealing to city council members and school board members alike.
The film takes a turn with the introduction of COVID-19 in early March 2020, picking up a sense of urgency that differs from the more structured first Act. As Homeroom shows, the seniors of today are highly adaptable, goal-oriented, and inspired teenagers. They use their iPhones to create TikTok videos, as well as catch up on the latest from ex-President Trump’s first impeachment trial. They’re paying attention. They don’t fear speaking up to authority figures; instead, they see teachers and faculty as their allies who share a common goal of unifying the school district in harmony.
From the everyday pressures of high school life to the unexpected introduction of COVID-19, Nicks lets the action and drama unfold onscreen without provocation, capturing a year’s worth of trauma that is uncomfortable to relive. The murders of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, “murder hornets”, and the racially-charged murder of Bay area teenager Nia Wilson are just some of the devastating events that this class has had to navigate through.
Homeroom proves that the youth have the power, and fostering safe environments for them to grow and learn will be key in creating tomorrow’s leaders. On a personal yet somber note, the film is dedicated to Karina Nicks, Peter’s 16-year-old daughter who died suddenly in September 2019. As the final installment to Nicks’ three-part trilogy of character-driven social issue films, Homeroom is a gratifying and inspiring ending to this chapter on Oakland, CA.
This review originally ran on January 29, 2021 during the Sundance Film Festival.
Distributed by Hulu. ‘Homeroom’ premieres on Hulu on Thursday, August 12th.
